It’s all very “Duggars in the Attic”.
By
Updated 1 year ago,January 16, 2024
Fan theories collected from r/Duggarsnark on Reddit.
I think she also kept saying how handsome he looked in his goofy military for Jesus getup.
I also remember her gushing about how great he looked when he was their chauffeur for Jessas engagement.
I dunno man, these kids either seem way too distant or way too close.
jumped-up_pantrygirl
I remember that episode vividly too!
When he went away to ALERT she was so upset!
Then there was the episode where Jessa said she wanted a future husband like John David.
No outside interaction, sexual repression, and familial role strain can do all sorts of crazy things.
May not have been Jim Bob or Michelle, but he learned his behavior somewhere.
Born_Slippee
I think this one actually makes total sense.
He learned the behavior somewhere.
I developed this theory going back and watching the old specials and episodes during quarantine…
These people are way too nice.
And then I remembered growing up in church circles and that nobody is actually that nice.
Were able to trace Joshs molestation timeline a bit through that period of time with his buzz cut.
We know that people outside of the family were aware of the abuse.
In my Christian circles mothers always seemed a more vilified when their kids had moral failings.
My mom would have guarded my innocence from even the chance Id have learned what abuse was.
So these fundies arent worried at all that the kids will talk even?
I think the Keller family raises interesting questions.
They literally gained nothing and did no social climbing by marrying Anna to sex pest Josh Duggar.
And they did so knowing about his past abuse, several years before the truth came out.
They never leveraged the knowledge?
Instead they were essentially cut out of their daughters life.
So whats going on there?
How did that fly?
Not only that, Josh Duggar is gloriously destroyed and revealed for what he truly is.
And yet the cult doesnt so much as publicly distance itself from them.
They continue marrying off their children with even better matches in the cult.
The weddings seem to get fancier every time.
So all of that said?
I can believe he first met her in a line at an event, but then what?
How did he know who she was, know where to find her family?
Jill & Derick this is the most obvious, they admit Jim Bob set them up.
Obviously the families coordinated.
Jinger & Jeremy I do think this is the least arranged match.
But I think Boob was and is more or less happy with Jeremy.
The marriage never wouldve happened if Boob wasnt OK with it.
Joy & Austin arranged by their families.
Joe needed a wife and Kendra was ripe for the plucking.
Boom, match made in creepy fundie heaven.
Josiah & Lauren wtf is this even?
Maybe she knows, maybe she doesnt.
But I think there is a substantial age difference between Michelle and her siblings.
It would be an interesting twist if her birth mother was her gay sister.
Bay-Area-Tanners
I definitely believe this.
ashbarr0ws
Michelle was born in 1966.
I also believe Josh still cheats and is still addicted to pornography.
lunasheldon
I feel like theyve definitely alluded to this.
I think Jeremy is also addicted to porn.
Ive also noticed being addicted to pornography is the trendy struggle of choice for young pastors.
A lot of them dont hide it and I think they use it make them relatable.
Hes definitely talked about his struggles and temptations though.
He gives Jinger access to his insta and computer to help keep him accountable.
Laura is Mark, oblivious of the subtext and thus the perfect chaperone.
Am I straight up speculating that theres incest in that family?
Yes, but I dont need to because we already know there has been in the past.
And I think it happened when she was very young.
Theres weird old family photos where her dress matches Michelles outfit instead of her sisters.
I think its also why Josh didnt prey on her.
Shes brought out mostly for filming, during which she displays her very childlike, seemingly intellectually-vacant demeanor.
