That said, there are certain celebrities who have made it into the god tier.
Here are those lucky seven.
spoilers ahead
1.
Hulu
For one, she actually helped Mabel further her investigation.
She even fired what she thought was a real gun!
Meryl Streep
Imagine a world in which Meryl Streep Meryl Streep cant get an acting job.
Thats whatOnly Murders in the Buildingwanted us to believe, somehow.
They even had her bust out some bad accents that detracted from the character she was playing.
Again, this was Meryl Streep doing that!
Also, she got better at acting.
Paul Rudd
While Streeps character eventually improved her acting skills, Paul Rudds character remained stuck in a rut.
On top of that, everyone hated him!
They even literally murdered him for it.
Tina Fey
As Cinda Canning, Tina Fey was essentially Sarah Koenig if Koenig were secretly a greedy psychopath.
Like theSerialcreator, she even wore similar glasses.
Amy Schumer
All Amy Schumer wanted to do was make out with Charles.
No cap that was her entire motivation for seeking the streaming rights toOnly Murders.
She even learned how to play bassoon just to have a shot at playing Jan!
Sting
If I remember correctly, Sting was the first major celeb to play themselves on this show.
And if Im wrong, you might doxx me or whatever.
This low-key elitist remained constantly bemused by the star-struck mortals around him.
Sting, the elitist!
Sting, the same one who cares about rainforests and stuff!
Matthew Broderick
Who knew Matthew Broderick was such a grating, needy perfectionist?
Certainly not us, the viewing public!
But sure made for an excellent joke.
